Patent vs Design - Which IP Right is Right for You?

Introduction: Understanding Intellectual Property Rights:

Intellectual Property Rights (IPR), such as patent vs design protection, are legal tools granted to creators and inventors for their intangible assets, such as inventions, artistic works, brand names, and trade secrets. These rights-encompassing patents, copyrights, trademarks, and trade secrets-give owners exclusive control over the use, distribution, and commercialization of their creations for a defined period.

The purpose of IP rights is basically to incentivize innovation and to allow creators to make a profit (not only financial, but also strategic) out of their work, which would in turn lead to reinvestment in R&D. By providing patent holders with a right to preclude unauthorized use or copying of their IPR, the regime creates an environment of competition between and among inventors and entities, resulting in the development of new and better products, technologies, and creative works that ensure economic growth and technological advancement.

What is a Patent?

A patent is a form of patent protection granted for an invention, giving the inventor legal protection to prevent others from making, using, selling, or importing the invention with consent for a limited period, typically 20 years. This form of Intellectual Property Rights is essential for protecting technical innovation. To qualify, the invention must be new, involve an inventive step, and be capable of industrial application. Patents not only safeguard inventors's interests but also benefit society by making technical information about new inventions publicly accessible, thus promoting further innovation.

The patent protection system in India is governed by the Patents Act, 1970 (No. 39 of 1970), as amended by the Patents (Amendment) Act, 2005, and the Patents Rules, 2003. The most recent amendment to the Patent Rules was made in 2024 in response to the ever-changing environment. Understanding how patents work is the first step in determining the right IP route in the Patent vs Design debate.

What is Design Right?

A design right is a form of intellectual property protection that safeguards the visual appearance or aesthetic design of a product, including its shape, configuration, pattern, ornamentation, colors, or texture. Design rights do not protect the functional aspects of a product; those are covered by patents, but rather how a product looks to the eye.

Design rights can be either registered or unregistered. Registered design rights offer stronger and longer-lasting protection. Initially, a design's registration period is ten years from the date of registration; however, if a claim to priority has been granted, the period is extended to ten years from the priority date. If an application is submitted in Form-3 to the Controller before the ten-year initial period has passed, along with the required costs, the initial registration period may be extended by an additional five years. Even after a design has been registered, the owner may still apply for such an extension. The design right in India is governed by the Design Act 2000.

Key Differences Between Patent vs Design Protection:

The table below highlights the major distinctions in the Patent vs Design framework:

When to Choose a Patent Over a Design Right:

In the Patent vs Design decision, you should opt for a patent when your primary goal is to protect the functional aspects or the way your invention works, rather than just its appearance. If competitors could create a product with a different look but the same functionality, a utility patent protection is the appropriate choice.

Key considerations for choosing patent protection:

• Functionality is Key: If your innovation lies in how something operates, its technical features, or its method of use, a utility patent offers protection for these aspects.
• Broader Protection: Utility patents generally provide broader and stronger protection, covering the underlying concept and preventing others from making, using, or selling any product that uses your invention's functional features, regardless of appearance.
• Competitive Advantage: If you want to prevent others from achieving the same result using a different design, a utility patent is necessary.

Know More About: Domain Registration

When a Design Right Is the Better Option:

A design right is the preferred form of protection when the unique value of your product lies in its visual appearance rather than its technical function.

Here are key situations where choosing the right design makes sense:

• Visual Appearance Is the Innovation: If your product's distinctiveness is primarily in its shape, pattern, color, or ornamentation.
• No New Technical Functionality: When your product does not introduce a new technical solution or functional improvement but stands out for its look, design rights are more suitable than patents, which require technical novelty.
• Cost and Speed: Design rights are generally less expensive and quicker to obtain compared to patents, making them attractive for businesses seeking efficient protection for product designs.
• Prior Disclosure: If your design has already been publicly disclosed, you may no longer be eligible for a patent due to lack of novelty, but design registration can still offer protection for the appearance.

Enforcement and Infringement: How They Differ:

Governing Laws and Enforcement:

1. Patents are governed by the Patents Act 1970, while designs are protected under the Designs Act, 2000.
2. Both patents and registered designs are enforced through civil courts by the right holder, but the specific statutes, procedures, and remedies differ.
3. The Patent vs Design choice also affects how enforcement and infringement proceedings are handled under Indian law.
4. Patent Enforcement and Litigation: Patent owners can file infringement suits in the appropriate court (often the district court or high court) where the defendant resides or conducts business.
5. Legal Remedies of Patent: Interim and permanent injunctions to stop ongoing or imminent infringement. Damages or an account of profits to compensate for losses due to infringement. Courts may grant ex parte interim injunctions to provide immediate relief.
6. Patent litigation is often complex due to the technical nature of patent protection, involving technical evidence and expert testimony, and cases can be lengthy and high stakes, especially in technology sectors.

Design Enforcement and Litigation:

1. Registered design rights owners can initiate civil action for infringement in the district court jurisdiction over the defendant or the place of infringement.
2. Legal Remedies of Design: Interim and permanent injunctions to restrain unauthorized use or copying of the design. Damages or recovery of profits made by the infringer.

Tips to Decide the Right IP Right for Your Innovation:

You can use these below criteria to make the right Patent vs Design decision for your innovation:

• Identify What Makes Your Innovation Unique: If your innovation's value lies in its functionality, technical features, or how it works, a patent is the right choice. If the visual appearance, shape, pattern, or ornamentation sets it apart, opt for a design right.
• Assess the Commercial Objective: For inventions that provide a new solution to a technical problem or offer improved performance, patent protection offers stronger and broader coverage. For products where market success depends on unique aesthetics, design rights are more suitable.
• Consider Eligibility Requirements: Patents require novelty, inventive step, and industrial applicability. Designs require novelty and originality in appearance but not technical inventiveness.
• Evaluate Cost and Complexity: Patent registration is more complex, time-consuming, and costly. Design registration is quicker, simpler, and more affordable, ideal for fast-moving consumer markets.
• Think About Duration of Protection: Patents offer up to 20 years of protection, while design rights typically last 10 years.

Can You Register Both a Patent and a Design?

Yes, you can register both a patent protection and a design right for the same product in India, provided each application meets the respective legal requirement. A patent protects the functional or technical aspects of an invention, while a design registration safeguards the unique visual appearance or aesthetic features of the product. This dual protection is especially useful when your innovation has both novel functionality and a distinctive look, allowing you to prevent others from copying either the technical workings or the external design.

To obtain both, you must file separate applications-one for the patent and another for the design registration-each with its process, documentation, and fees. This strategy maximizes your intellectual property protection, covering both how your product works and how it appears in the market. Registering both helps you secure advantages on both sides of the Patent vs Design debate.

Conclusion

Choosing between patent and design protection depends on the unique features and commercial objectives of your innovation. Patent protection safeguards the technical and functional aspects of inventions, offering robust and long-term protection but requiring a more complex and costly registration process. Design rights, on the other hand, protect the visual and aesthetic elements of products with a simpler, faster, and more affordable application procedure.

For innovations where functionality and technical advancement are key, patents are the preferred route. If your product's competitive edge lies in its appearance, design protection is more suitable. In many cases, combining both forms of protection can offer comprehensive coverage, securing both how your product works and how it looks.

Ultimately, choosing the right IP protection-Patent vs Design-depends on your product's features and goals.

Ready to Protect Your Innovation? Whether you're safeguarding a breakthrough invention or a unique product design, choosing the right IP protection is critical. Our experts can guide you through patent and design registration in India. Contact us today for a free consultation and secure your intellectual property the right way.

Read Also:

• Logo Design Services for Trademark and Company